Remdesivir has very little effect on Covid-19 mortality, WHO findsAshley Tavirima
Remdesivir has very little effect on Covid-19 mortality, WHO finds
Results from gold-standard trial described as sobering, as drug found not to improve survival rates
Remdesivir, one of the big treatment hopes for Covid-19, has very little effect on preventing deaths, according to a large and comprehensive trial run by the World Health Organization.
The drug, which made by the US biotech firm Gilead, has been talked up as a potential cure and was taken by Donald Trump. A trial in the US had previously showed it reduced the length of stay in hospital. But the gold-standard Solidarity WHO trial, which was based on a far larger sample – 3,000 people on the drug, compared with as many who were not – showed Remdesivir had little effect on deaths over 28 days.
Gilead was told about the results on 23 September, 10 days before publication, and was given a first draft of study on 28 September. WHO said the company was told the outcome in advance as part of an agreement to provide the drug for free.
On 8 October, Gilead signed a contract for 500,000 doses of the drug with the European commission – which did not know the results – at a cost of €850m (£733m).
The agreement to disclose the results to the company before publication was made at the beginning of the trial, said Dr Soumya Swaminathan, chief scientist at the WHO. “It is an agreement in good faith,” she said, adding that it allowed Gilead to check whether any errors had been made, but did not allow the company to change the analysis or conclusions.
Many countries have already put Remdesivir on their treatment list for Covid-19 patients, based on the much smaller US study that found the drug shortened hospital stay.
The WHO’s guideline committee will now look at the data from its trial and others and decide what recommendations to make about the drug.
Three other drugs were trialled in the Solidarity study, which has recruited more than 12,000 patients across 30 countries, and none of had very much effect on mortality. They were hydroxychloroquine, which has already been found to have no benefit by the University of Oxford’s Recovery trial, lopinavir, an antiretroviral used in HIV treatment, and interferon, given as an injection under the skin.
“Interferon was disappointing,” said Oxford’s Prof Sir Richard Peto, who was the chief statistician in the trial. “This regime didn’t do much for survival.”
However, it is still possible that interferon given in other ways or in different formulations may have an effect.
The remdesivir results constitute the bulk of the evidence for the drugs being used, Peto said. “It is more than three times as big as all the other evidence in the world put together.”
The Solidarity trial had to be taken seriously, he continued. “The quality of this trial is excellent. This is real world evidence. The phrase has been hijacked by people – a lot of wrong answers have come out from people trying to play games by avoiding randomisation
With Remdesivir, there were 300 deaths among people randomly assigned to the drug and 300 among others not on the drug. “It doesn’t guarantee there is exactly no effect, but it does very much constrain what it is possible to claim,” he said.
Martin Landray, professor of medicine and epidemiology at Oxford, and one of the leads on the Recovery trial, said the results of the Solidarity trial were important but sobering.
“Four different drugs were studied in over 11,000 patients at 405 hospitals in 30 countries. The trial is beautiful in its simplicity and clarity of purpose – large, randomised and focused on the ultimate clinical outcome of survival. None of the four treatments studied – hydroxychloroquine, lopinavir, interferon, Remdesivir – showed worthwhile benefits.”
Remdesivir has received plenty of attention over the past few months and was one of a number of treatments given to Trump. It is now recommended in some clinical guidelines. But there have been significant concerns about supply, cost, and access. The cost varies around the world but is about $2,000 (£1,450) a treatment course, which involves the drug being administered by intravenous infusion for five to 10 days.
“The WHO Solidarity trial found that Remdesivir had no meaningful effect on mortality,” Landray said. “Covid affects millions of people and their families around the world. It is not a rare disease. We need scalable, affordable, and equitable treatments.
“The WHO Solidarity trial has done the world a huge favour by producing clear, independent and robust results, showing once more the value of large randomised trials in providing the knowledge we need to tackle the worst consequences of this pandemic.”
Creative Commons Disclosure
About Mandatory Compliance
Mandatory Compliance is the leading UK provider of CPDUK accredited healthcare and social care training courses, e-learning programs and Ofqual approved qualifications.
Click on the links below to find out more about our accredited e-learning courses and qualifications:
- Business Administration
- Charities an Volunteers
- Child Care Serdvices
- Clinical Commissioning Groups
- Clinical Governance
- Clinical Skills Development
- Corporate Governance
- CQC Compliance
- Education and Training
- Equality and Diversity
- FE Colleges And Universities
- Finance Management
- Health and Safety at Work – Online Training Courses
- Health & Social Care
- Health Law and Ethics
- Human Resource Management
- Information Governance (GDPR)
- IT and Technology Management
- Leadership and Management
- Local Authorities
- Long Term Conditions
- Mental Health Awareness
- Primary Care Services
- Public Health
- Research and Development
- Risk Management
- Safeguarding People at Risk
- Sales and Marketing
- Statutory Mandatory Training
- Work Skills and Development
- Workforce Development.
Contact our Support Team on 02476100090 or via Email for more courses relating to the Care Quality Commission (CQC) and other regulatory compliance requirements.